Victorian and early 1900s homes
Tall two-story homes with clapboard, ornate trim, and wraparound porches. These take careful scraping and spot-priming, and the detail work is where a good crew earns its keep.
PaintYour World With Happiness
Need Painters in New Carlisle That You Can Actually Count On?
We show up on time, finish on schedule, and deliver a first-class experience from beginning to end - our reviews prove it.
- Free Estimates
- Licensed, Bonded & Insured
- Competitive, Upfront Pricing
Responsive, Reliable and Quality Painters in New Carlisle, IN
Welcome to Brothers Colors Painting! Whether you’re planning to paint the interior or exterior of your home, commercial property, HOA, condo, warehouse, office complex or specialty property – we are the professional painting partner you can rely on to paint your world with happiness. Our teams of experienced painters are committed to delivering exceptional results that bring your vision to life.
Hundreds of customers across a diverse scope of projects choose us year after year to paint their worlds with happiness – schedule an estimate today and find out why!
What is Brothers Colors Painting's Mission?
Our mission is to paint the world with happiness by providing companies and families with quality service, effective communication, minimal disruption, competitive pricing, and reliability.
Schedule Free Estimate
Fill out the form below or call us at (574) 387-3318
South Bend, In - Organic
WHAT CAN WE HELP YOU WITH?
New Carlisle Residential & Commercial Painting
Local painters, not a call center
House Painting in New Carlisle, Indiana
New Carlisle sits about 15 miles west of South Bend on US-20, with a historic downtown along Michigan Street, Victorian and early 1900s homes on the streets around it, and Hudson Lake and Bendix Woods just outside town. It has stayed a small town while the industrial land to the east has grown, which means a mix of well-kept older homes, mid-century ranches, and lake cottages.
The older housing is the story here. Original wood siding, tall windows, porch columns, and decorative trim all need patient prep, and many homes have several layers of paint going back decades. Our South Bend crews are a quick drive down US-20, and we treat New Carlisle homes with the same process as anything in town.
What we see in New Carlisle homes
Layers of old paint
Homes this age often carry decades of paint. We stabilize what is sound, remove what is failing, and prime so the new coat has something solid to hold onto.
Hudson Lake cottages
Lake cottages and year-round lake homes take extra moisture and shade. We use mildew-resistant coatings and can stain decks and docks in the same trip.
What New Carlisle homeowners ask us for most
Exterior and interior house paintingFull repaints of historic homes, ranches, and lake cottages, inside and out.
Deck and patio stainingCleaning, sanding, and staining of porches, decks, and lakeside patios.
Cabinet refinishingSprayed enamel finishes on older wood kitchens and vanities.
Commercial paintingDowntown storefronts and small businesses painted around your hours.
Also serving nearby
Good to know
New Carlisle Painting FAQs
Do you charge extra to come out to New Carlisle?
No. New Carlisle and Olive Township are part of our regular South Bend service area. Estimates are free and there is no travel charge.
When should I schedule an exterior repaint in New Carlisle?
Exterior paint needs surface and air temperatures above 50°F to cure, so the season in northern Indiana runs from about May through October. Spring fills up first. If you want a summer date, reach out in late winter or early spring. Interior work is scheduled year-round.
Can you handle the detailed trim on a Victorian home?
Yes. Porch columns, brackets, window casings, and multiple trim colors are hand-brushed work, and our crews do a lot of it in older neighborhoods around South Bend. We will walk the details with you at the estimate.
My home was built before 1978. Does that change anything?
It can. Older homes in New Carlisle may have layers of lead-based paint under the surface. Tell us the age of your home when you request an estimate and we will walk you through how we handle prep on older homes so dust and chips are contained.
Do you paint lake homes on Hudson Lake?
Yes. Lake homes take more moisture and shade than in-town houses, so we use mildew-resistant, flexible exterior coatings and can take care of decks, docks, and porches at the same time.
Do you also work in Rolling Prairie and Hamlet?
Yes. Everything along the US-20 and US-30 corridors between South Bend and Michigan City is inside our service area. Call us and we will confirm scheduling.
We Painted Happiness in More than 250+ New Carlisle Homes
Before
After
Before
After
More Recent Projects
Exterior repaint, gambrel-roof home
Residential
Two-story exterior with porch and shutters
Residential
Cabinet refinishing, white shaker kitchen
Residential
Dining room accent color and trim
Residential
Church sanctuary walls and ceiling
Commercial
Pergola and patio staining
Residential
New-construction apartment building
Commercial
Commercial garage walls and safety striping
Commercial
BROTHERS COLORS PAINTING BRAND PROMISES
HERE ARE SOME REASONS OUR CUSTOMERS LOVE US
Quality Service
By understanding your results and process expectations, and holding ourselves accountable to high-quality service, you’ll have peace of mind knowing your project is in good hands – leaving you free to focus on everything else that needs your attention.
Effective Communication
Responsive, concise, friendly, and transparent communication leads to happier outcomes. From providing estimates, to managing change orders and the final walk-through – we seek to understand our customers.
Minimal Disruption
As exciting as fresh colors are, we understand having crews in your home or place of business can shake things up a bit. By working with your schedule, respecting you and your property, and delivering on time, our goal is to make the process of painting your world with happiness as pleasant as possible.
Competitive Pricing
The saying goes: “price is what you pay, value is what you get”. We work hard to optimize operations, maintain skilled craftsmanship with quality products, and keep pricing fair to deliver exceptional, long-lasting value.
Reliability
A high ratio between what we say and what we do goes far beyond quality guarantees and being licensed, bonded, and insured. We work promptly and focus on delivering your vision. No extending jobs for days (or weeks) longer than expected by jumping back and forth.
READ WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS HAVE TO SAY
"I bought my first house a few years ago even though the paint on the walls needed some serious help. A few things went wrong in the beginning so I had to postpone the house painting. Even now I have a small budget to work with! Keeping that in mind I had a few businesses come out and give me a quote.
Brothers Colors Painting came out and gave me a price I could live. Not only was I blown away by the friendliness and professionalism I was blown away by the job they did!!!!! They will be doing all of my house beautification projects!"
"Patrick and Matt truly are professionals with their painting. I had a number of unique walls and colors in my home. They were prompt and efficient. They finished the job on time, and were very accommodating for my special requests. Their estimate was more than fair, and the colors were exactly what I wanted. Such a pleasure to work with. Will hire again."
"Thank you so much! You guys are so awesome.. and I'm embarrassed, I realized while I was talking and cooking I didn't put any mayo or mustard on your sandwiches..... I'm so sorry I was trying to do so much multitasking.. I neglected my painters, I'm sooo sorry your guys are awesome!"
"Patrick and the crew did a wonderful job painting our cabinets. He was very professional and knew his colors to help me pick out a color to go with our countertops and decor. I highly recommend him and his team!"
More Happy Customers
Our Partner Brands
GET IN TOUCH WITH US!
We are open 8AM - 6PM, Monday - Friday to answer all of your questions. Set up a free estimate by calling us or by filling out this form.
Contact Brothers Colors Painting
Service Areas
South Bend, Granger, Plymouth, North Liberty, New Carlisle, Michigan City, Elkhart, Goshen, Laporte.
Call Us
(574) 387-3318Email Us
brotherscolorspainting@gmail.com
Hours
Monday - Friday 8AM - 6PM
Schedule Free Estimate
Fill out the form below or call us at (574) 387-3318
South Bend, In - Organic